Saturday, April 18, 2009

Review of Feast of Souls

Feast of Souls is the first book in the Magister trilogy, the latest series by C.S. Friedman, perhaps best known for her Coldfire trilogy. The second book, Wings of Wrath, was just released in hardcover in February. It has yet to be announced when the final book Legacy of Kings will be available. After reading C.S. Friedman's debut novel, the space opera In Conquest Born, I knew I had to read more of her work and after all I had heard about this one, it sounded right up my alley. Feast of Souls is a dark epic fantasy containing a wide cast of characters and many elements that are somewhat familiar to readers of the genre, yet they are well executed and the nature of magic in the world is interesting enough to keep it from feeling stale.

In Feast of Souls, magic requires great sacrifice, for those who practice it can only do so at the cost of shortening their own life. Small spells may only shave a few seconds or minutes from their time remaining but larger ones could remove a few years from the caster's total lifespan. The prologue introduces us to Imnea, a witch in her mid-thirties who feels about eighty years old due to the amount of magic she has used. Although she has retired from spellcasting to preserve what little time she has left, the people she helped throughout the years despise her for her selfishness in refusing to give up the last little bit of life she has left to help them. When a woman comes to Imnea requesting she save her child from a plague, Imnea resists at first but ends up giving up her life to help the boy. Meanwhile, his young sister Kamala watches and determines to become the first female magister rather than die from using her ability.

The magisters are a small group of men who can wield magic to their heart's content without dying. Many of them have survived for centuries despite rather liberal use of their power. Their secret of longevity is only known to themselves and no woman has ever been able to accept the consequences of becoming a magister, for the cost of magic is still life itself and magisters simply use another person to fuel their spells. When the Prince Andovan is diagnosed with the Wasting disease associated with those who are bound to a magister, their ugly secret is threatened - a truth that must remain hidden from the general public so the vulnerabilities of the magisters is not exposed.

This book was a little difficult to get into toward the beginning, as it switched back and forth between characters and introduced the main players and their motivations. However, once the story got going, it was difficult to put down and I ended up staying up late one night to finish it because I just had to know how it ended as soon as possible. The story is far from finished, though, with many questions left unanswered in the first installment of this trilogy.

Overall, there were many plot elements and character descriptions that seemed like very typical fantasy tropes. An old, nearly forgotten threat to the world returns true to the prophecy that what had happened before would happen again. Most people regarded this danger as an old myth but a few chosen to defend remember it. There is a mad king (both crazy-mad and temperamental-mad) who is led astray by a corrupt adviser. A mysterious wizard seems to know more about events than he is willing to share. These are still handled well, but there are two main parts that make a Feast of Souls stand out from the typical fantasy novel: the examination of power via effects of wielding magic and Kamala.

C.S. Friedman's portrayal of power is harsh. It's fleeting for those who are not cold enough to use the energy of other people. The only way to remain strong is to be a survivor, to be willing to look out for yourself first and remain alive no matter what the consequences - even if it means that somewhere an innocent person dies to keep you hale. Although the means of becoming a magister is horrible, they do some good. Power is not always exercised for selfish reasons - one may use the life force of a single person to save several people.

Most of the characters did not seem particularly well developed or out of the ordinary to me in this largely plot-driven novel - the one big exception to this was Kamala. From early on, the one character whose story always hooked me and kept me reading was Kamala's. The powerful scene in the prologue showed a defining moment in shaping her life and from then on I was very intrigued by the young woman who had the strength and determination to pursue a path knowing that all others of her gender had not been able to follow it. She has not had a happy life (her mother was poor and sold Kamala to men as a prostitute at a young age) but has come out more resilient instead of weakened. Kamala is not a "good" character but she is not come across as an "evil" person, either. It is perfectly reasonable that she would be hardened, but she is not completely heartless.

Feast of Souls is the beginning of what promises to be an entertaining dark fantasy series. Although it has some obvious characteristics of the genre, there are enough elements done well that it's well worth the read and I'm looking forward to the next book (although I will be waiting for it to come to paperback).


Read the prologue (scroll down)

Other Reviews:


ediFanoB said...

I read your good review with interest because a few days ago someone highly recommended my the COLDFIRE trilogy.
It seems I have to discover the books of
C.S. Friedman.

Kristen said...

ediFanoB - I've been highly recommended the Coldfire trilogy as well and own the whole series although I have yet to read it. It's supposed to be very good dark fantasy with anti-hero protagonists.

orannia said...

I read the Coldfire trilogy a few years ago now, but it is very good...dark...with characters that cross the line...

Thank you for the review Kristen. Methinks it is time to read some more CS Friedman books :)

Oh, and I saw you finished Cormabis. Am not sure if I will read your review since I have yet to read The Mirador and don't want any spoilers. May I suggest Wicked Lovely as the next book. I really like Melissa Marr's faerie...

Kristen said...

Orannia - Characters that cross the line, hm? Definitely sounds intriguing! I don't know why I've had those books for so long without reading them. Well, yes I do - the books all look long and I haven't wanted to invest the time required to read the whole series. Sounds like I need to just get over it and read them anyway, though.

I wouldn't blame you in the least if you didn't read my Corambis review since you haven't read the previous book - I wouldn't either! There is something big that happens right at the end of The Mirador and Corambis picks up right where it left off so it's better to be safe and avoid reviews of the newest book.

Thanks for the suggestion for what to read next! I think I do want to read something by a new-to-me author since I haven't for a little while so I am considering it.